Post by nurnobi85 on Feb 12, 2024 7:28:12 GMT
Judge are prohibited from holding a management position or technical position in a civil society, association or foundation of any nature or purpose. The rapporteur's assessment is that the seal is a mechanism found by society capable of maintaining the independence of magistrates in carrying out their duties and functions, “with promptness, correctness and punctuality”. The CNJ inspector highlighted in his vote that the Superior Court of Sports Justice is an integral body of the structure of the Brazilian Football Confederation. Furthermore, it is a legal entity governed by private law and whose functions assigned to its members are considered as performance of technical activity.
In other words there is total incompatibility between the functions of magistrate and member of a Sports Justice court. If this understanding prevails, other occupants of positions under the same conditions will have to leave their positions. Pádua Ribeiro's vote accepted the disciplinary complaint to Dubai Email List remove judge Luiz Zveiter from the STJD within a maximum period of 15 days and proposed the adoption of a resolution issued by the National Council of Justice to standardize the treatment of the issue within the scope of the Judiciary. Zveiter claims there was no irregularity in the accumulation of positions.
According to him, there would be no prohibition in the text of the Constitution, or even in Brazilian legislation, on the combination of the two activities. At the time of the trial, there was some discussion about the repercussions of Zveiter's possible departure. The inspector then thought it best to say that Zveiter's departure would not disrupt the progress of the competition. According to the minister, what is being analyzed by the CNJ is a matter of administrative disciplinary order relating to the judiciary and not the decisions taken by the magistrate as president of the STJD. “From my understanding there will be no impact on the Brazilian championship”, concluded the inspector.
In other words there is total incompatibility between the functions of magistrate and member of a Sports Justice court. If this understanding prevails, other occupants of positions under the same conditions will have to leave their positions. Pádua Ribeiro's vote accepted the disciplinary complaint to Dubai Email List remove judge Luiz Zveiter from the STJD within a maximum period of 15 days and proposed the adoption of a resolution issued by the National Council of Justice to standardize the treatment of the issue within the scope of the Judiciary. Zveiter claims there was no irregularity in the accumulation of positions.
According to him, there would be no prohibition in the text of the Constitution, or even in Brazilian legislation, on the combination of the two activities. At the time of the trial, there was some discussion about the repercussions of Zveiter's possible departure. The inspector then thought it best to say that Zveiter's departure would not disrupt the progress of the competition. According to the minister, what is being analyzed by the CNJ is a matter of administrative disciplinary order relating to the judiciary and not the decisions taken by the magistrate as president of the STJD. “From my understanding there will be no impact on the Brazilian championship”, concluded the inspector.